StaTuesday: Brewers’ Woodruff a pitcher who rakes

Anyone who saw last year’s National League Championship Series knows Brandon Woodruff can rake. After all, how many left-handed hitters take the Dodgers’ Clayton Kershaw deep, like Woodruff did in Game 1?

(The answer is not many: Kershaw has allowed just 39 homers in 1,585 at-bats to lefties in the regular season over his career to date and Woodruff is the only left-handed hitting pitcher to ever homer off Kershaw.)

More Brewers coverage

Woodruff began this season on a four-game hitting streak – which included a pinch-hitting appearance. That might seem trivial, but in Brewers history it’s tied for the ninth-longest hitting streak by a pitcher. The record is six games, by Yovani Gallardo and Marty Pattin, although the latter did it with the Seattle Pilots. Six pitchers own five-game hit streaks: Gallardo, Junior Guerra, Taylor Jungmann, Chris Narveson, Wes Obermueller and Jamey Wright.

Over those four games, Woodruff went 5-for-7. He’s tailed off a bit since then, but,entering Tuesday night’s game in which he is scheduled to start, he’s batting .353 on the season.

Can he keep up that rate over the course of the entire 2019 season? Only two other pitchers in Brewers history have batted over .300 (minimum 15 at-bats). Woodruff currently has the second-highest average.

PLAYER YEAR AB AVG OBP SLG
Wes Obermueller 2004 39 .400 .462 .862
Brandon Woodruff 2019 17 .353 .389 .471
Chris Narveson 2010 49 .327 .365 .347
Glendon Rusch 2002 66 .288 .299 .333
Taylor Jungmann 2015 37 .270 .289 .324
Brooks Kieschnick 2004 32 .270 .324 .365
Seth McClung 2008 18 .263 .263 .316
Yovani Gallardo 2010 63 .254 .329 .508
Yovani Gallardo 2007 40 .250 .268 .475
Ruben Quevedo 2001 16 .250 .250 .250

For those who might clamor about Kieschnick’s appearance above, in 2004 the only position he played in the field was pitcher. He wasn’t even used in the outfield or as a designated hitter that year, as he did in 2003, but did pinch hit.

Woodruff’s batting average isn’t just a nice accomplishment in Milwaukee history. In the DH era (since 1973), his .353 batting average is tied for 15th among pitchers over a single season (min. 17 AB).

No one has hit as high as Woodruff’s current.353 since 2011, when Cincinnati’s Dontrelle Willis, in the final year of his major-league career, hit .387 and San Diego’s Wade LeBlanc batted .364.

PLAYER YEAR AB AVG OBP SLG
Allen Watson 1995 36 .417 .447 .528
Steve Blass 1973 24 .417 .417 .500
Don Robinson 1992 18 .389 .389 .556
Dontrelle Willis 2011 31 .387 .387 .645
Wes Obermueller 2004 39 .400 .462 .862
Dan Schatzeder 1986 26 .385 .484 .654
Rick Rhoden 1980 40 .375 .390 .525
Atlee Hammaker 1989 19 .368 .368 .421
Larry Chrisenson 1980 19 .368 .455 .526
Wade LeBlanc 2011 22 .364 .391 .364
Dan Haren 2010 55 .364 .375 .527
Bill Lee 1981 22 .364 .364 .500
Orel Hershiser 1993 73 .356 .373 .411
Mark Portugal 1994 48 .354 .360 .500
Brandon Woodruff 2019 17 .353 .389 .471
Chris Hammond 1991 34 .353 .389 .441

Willis was known as a good-hitting pitcher during his career, and finished with a .244 batting average. Most of the others, though, have that one good season and fade away back into the, well, category of most pitchers. Obermueller, for example, was 7-for-54 (.130) combined in every other season except for hit .385 year in 2004.

Woodruff is an exception. He’s always hit.

In 2016 in Double-A Biloxi he batted .292 and counted a double and home run among his 11 hits. In 2018 with Triple-A Colorado Springs he hit a respectable (for a pitcher) .231.

In his first year with the Brewers, in 2017, Woodruff went 2-for-10 with a walk. In 2018, he was 2-for-8 with a home run and a walk. And then of course there was his postseason HR off Kershaw (he’d come to bat three times that series and reach base twice).

In 2019, manager Craig Counsell has batted him eighth once and, as mentioned, used him as a pinch hitter.

Entering Tuesday’s game, Woodruff is hitting .286 over his career (with a .342 on-base percentage and .429 slugging percentage). Since the major leagues has consisted of the American and National leagues back in 1901, among pitchers with at least 30 career at-bats, Woodruff ranks 19th all time.

And of the others in the top 20, only seven (including Woodruff) played after World War II and none since 1986.

PLAYER YEARS AB AVG
Terry Forster 1971-86 78 .397
John Russell 1917-22 30 .367
Cookie Cuccurullo 1943-45 52 .327
Al Grabowski 1929-30 49 .327
John Martina 1924 43 .326
Forrest Thompson 1948-49 40 .325
Fin Wilson 1914-15 37 .324
Frank Foreman 1901-02 91 .319
Elmer Koestner 1910-14 54 .315
Tom Baker 1935-38 58 .310
Renie Martin 1979-84 83 .301
Lee Stine 1934-38 30 .300
Dave Jolly 1953-57 48 .292
Johnny Rutherford 1952 31 .290
Bill Bayne 1919-30 214 .290
Rex Cecil 1944-45 38 .289
Red Phillips 1934-36 45 .289
Bob Trice 1953-55 52 .288
Brandon Woodruff 2017-19 35 .286
Alan Koch 1963-64 35 .286

Woodruff is hardly the only Brewers pitcher who can hit. Milwaukee hurlers are batting .189 combined this year. Jhoulys Chacin is 3 for 12 (.250) with a homer, Corbin Burnes 2-for-6 (.333) and Aaron Wilkerson homered in his only at-bat.

Maybe it’s time to bring back #pitcherswhorake.

Dave Heller is the author of Ken Williams: A Slugger in Ruth’s Shadow (a Larry Ritter Book Award nominee), Facing Ted Williams – Players From the Golden Age of Baseball Recall the Greatest Hitter Who Ever Lived and As Good As It Got: The 1944 St. Louis Browns