The Suez Canal is being widened. Will it be enough to stop another ship getting stuck?

In an effort to avoid a repeat of the event, in mid-May, the Suez Canal Authority (SCA) announced it had started dredging work to widen and deepen the southern part of the canal where the Ever Given was jammed. The 30-kilometer-long area will be widened by 40 meters (131 feet) to the east and deepened to 72 feet, up from 66 feet, according to the SCA. Plans also include extending the second lane near the Great Bitter Lake, which opened in 2015, by 10 kilometers (6 miles) — allowing two-way traffic along an 82 kilometer (51 mile) stretch. The work is intended for “maximizing the canal’s efficiency and shortening the vessels’ transit time, as well as raising the navigation safety,” said a press release from the SCA. But there are still questions as to whether this will be enough to prevent future blockages. “The widening of the canal is a smart move,” Sal Mercogliano, a maritime historian at Campbell University in North Carolina, tells CNN. “The question that I have is if you widen the canal, then will vessel operators make their vessels bigger?”Over the past 50 years the container carrying capacity of the biggest ships has increased by 1,500%, and doubled over the past decade alone, according to shipping insurer Allianz Global Corporate and Speciality. The largest ships can carry up to 24,000 containers and measure over 200 feet at their widest point — wider than a standard American football field. The Ever Given — which can hold up to 20,000 containers but was only carrying 18,000 at the time of grounding — is in the top 1% globally in terms of vessel size, measuring 400 meters (1,312 feet) long and 59 meters (194 feet) wide.Shipping companies argue that bigger ships are more efficient at carrying large volumes of cargo across the globe and — in normal conditions — they are able to pass through the Suez. But “it’s a very narrow margin of error,” says Mercogliano. If there are strong winds — as in the case of the Ever Given — or bad visibility, ultra-large vessels risk getting stuck. The case of the Ever Given illustrated the potential repercussions of a blockage. At the time, shipping news journal Lloyd’s List estimated the ship was holding up roughly $9.6 billion of goods each day. The Suez Canal handles about 12% of global trade, with around 19,000 ships passing through each year. The extension proposed by the SCA will help reduce the risk of ships getting stuck, but it will not erase it, says Ioannis Theotokas, a professor in the Department of Maritime Studies at the University of Piraeus, Greece.”It will never be enough unless a second lane is opened in the southern part,” he tells CNN. But he believes that container ships are unlikely to get any bigger, so further widenings may not be necessary.”Increasing the size of ships caused extensive investments in ports to support them. A further increase would require further investments,” which are not readily available, he adds. Future routesHowever, the Ever Given incident did prompt discussion of alternative routes. The canal’s strategic position — connecting the Mediterranean to the Red Sea and offering the shortest sea route between Europe and Asia — is key to its influence. Without the Suez, shipments between the two continents would have to travel around the Cape of Good Hope at the southern tip of Africa. Some shipping companies opted for this route while the Suez was blocked, despite it taking more than double the time.”It’s no coincidence that soon after the Ever Given incident, Russia made comments of the attractiveness of alternative routes, namely the Northern Sea Route,” says Theotokas. That route runs along the Arctic coast of Russia, from the Kara Sea to the Bering Strait. An official from the nuclear firm Rosatom, which is in charge of the development of the route, told a Russian news agency that “the Suez precedent has shown how fragile any route between Europe and Asia is,” and urged for development of alternative routes like the Northern Sea Route. Soon after these comments, shipping company MSC, the world’s second largest container line, doubled down on its commitment to avoid the Northern Sea Route on environmental grounds. Arctic shipping could increase pollution and contribute to melting sea ice. Theotokas believes the position of the Suez as a world trade route will remain strong. “Shipping companies are always prepared to handle risk such as Ever Given,” he says. The SCA’s extension will just make them more comfortable in doing so. “The widening of the canal will make it easier for salvage operations … even if it does not erase the risk of repeating the incident,” he says.